Problem 8.4. Frequency of a beam supported by springs

We wish to reduce the natural frequency of the beam given in the previous problem by 20% by applying springs at the supports. Determine
the required spring constant if
a) only the uniform mass is considered,
b) only the concentrated mass is considered,
c) both the uniform and the concentrated masses are considered.

Bending stiffness of the beam is: EI = 18640 kNm2, distributed mass is: m = 42.2 kg/m, the concentrated mass is: M = 150 kg. Length of the beam is L = 7 m.

Solve Problem

Solve

Problem a)

Spring constant, c [kN/mm]=

Problem b)

Spring constant, c [kN/mm]=

Problem c)

Spring constant, c [kN/mm]=

Do you need help?

Steps

Step by step

Follow steps of Example 55.
Problem a)

Step 1.  Calculate natural frequency of the beam built-in at both ends with uniform mass.

Show frequency, fm,1

See Eq.(8-49) and the previous problem (Problem 8.3 b)) .
fm,1=5.1fmss=5.1π2EI4mL4=5.1π2×18640×1034×42.2×7.04=48.11 Hz

Step 2.  Determine natural frequency of the beam supported by springs with uniform mass.

Show frequency, fm,2

Equation (8-15)

fm,2=12π2cmL

Step 3.  Approximate fundamental frequency of the beam with uniform mass applying Föppl’s summation theorem.

Show frequency, fm

See Table 30 and Eq.(8-59).
1fm2=1fm,12+1fm,22=148.112+4π22c42.2×7.0

Step 4.  Express spring constant from the condition that the natural frequency must be reduced by 20%.

Show spring constant, cm

fm=0.8fm,1=    1fm,12+1fm,221=0.82fm,12      fm,22=fm,1210.8211=1.78×fm,12  cm=4π2mL2  fm,22=2π2×42.2×7.0×1.78×48.11=24.0×106Nm=24.0 kNmm

Problem b)

Step 1.  Calculate natural frequency of the beam built-in at both ends with concentrated mass.

Show frequency, fM,1

See Eq.(8-53) and the previous problem (Problem 8.3 b)) .
fM,1=12πkM=12π192EIML3=12π192×18640×103150×7.03=41.98 Hz

Step 2.  Determine natural frequency of the beam supported by springs with concentrated mass.

Show frequency, fM,2

Eq.(8-15)

fM,2=12π2cM

Step 3.  Approximate fundamental frequency of the beam with concentrated mass applying Föppl’s summation theorem.

Show frequency, fM

See Table 30 and Eq.(8-59).
1fM2=1fM,12+1fM,22    1fM2=141.982+4π2M2c

Step 4.  Express spring constant from the condition that the natural frequency must be reduced by 20%.

Show spring constant, cM

fM=0.8fM,1=    1fM,12+1fM,221=0.82fM,12      fM,22=fM,1210.8211=1.78fM,12  cM=4π2M2  fM,22=2π2×150×1.78×41.97=9.27×106Nm=9.27kNmm

Problem c)

Step 1.  Determine natural frequency of the beam built-in at both ends with uniform and additional concentrated masses.

Show frequency, f1

Eigenfrequency with both masses is approximated with Dunkerley’s summation theorem.

See Table 30 and the previous problem (Problem 8.3 b)).
1f12=1fm,12+1fM,12      f1=148.112+141.9820.5=31.63 Hz

 

Step 2.  Determine natural frequency of the beam supported by springs with uniform and additional concentrated masses.

Show frequency, f2

Eq.(8-15).
 1f22=4π22cmL+M

Step 3.  Approximate fundamental frequency of the beam with both masses applying Föppl’s summation theorem.

Show frequency, f

See Table 30 and Eq.(8-59).
1f2=1f12+1f22      1f2=131.632+4π2(mL+M)2c

Step 4.  Express spring constant from the condition that the natural frequency must be reduced by 20%.

Show spring constant, c

See Table 30 and Eq.(8-59).
f=0.8f1=    1f12+1f221=0.82f12      f22=f1210.8211=1.78f12  c=4π2(mL+M)2  f22=2π2×(42.2×7.0+150)×1.78×31.632=15.63×106Nm=15.63kNmm

Results

Worked out solution

Follow steps of Example 55.
Problem a)

First the natural frequency is calculated assuming that the beam is built-in at both ends (only the uniform mass is considered).

See Eq.(8-49) and the previous problem (Problem 8.3 b)) .
fm,1=5.1fmss=5.1π2EI4mL4=5.1π2×18640×1034×42.2×7.04=48.11 Hz

Then the natural frequency of the beam is calculated, when it is supported by springs (with uniform mass).

Eq.(8-15)

fm,2=12π2cmL

The fundamental frequency of the beam with both supports (and with uniform mass) is approximated by Föppl’s summation theorem.

See Table 30 and Eq.(8-59).
1fm2=1fm,12+1fm,22=148.112+4π22c42.2×7.0

Spring constant can be expressed from the condition that the natural frequency must be reduced by 20%:

fm=0.8fm,1=    1fm,12+1fm,221=0.82fm,12      fm,22=fm,1210.8211=1.78×fm,12  cm=4π2mL2  fm,22=2π2×42.2×7.0×1.78×48.11=24.0×106Nm=24.0 kNmm

Problem b)

Natural frequency of the beam assuming built-in ends (with concentrated mass) is

See Eq.(8-53) and the previous problem (Problem 8.3 b)) .
fM,1=12πkM=12π192EIML3=12π192×18640×103150×7.03=41.98 Hz

Assuming springs supports (and concentrated mass) the natural frequancy results in:

Eq.(8-15)

fM,2=12π2cM

The fundamental frequency of the beam (with concentrated mass) is approximated by Föppl’s summation theorem.

See Table 30 and Eq.(8-59).
1fM2=1fM,12+1fM,22   →    1fM2=141.982+4π2M2c

Spring constant is expressed from the condition that the natural frequency must be reduced by 20%.

fM=0.8fM,1=    1fM,12+1fM,221=0.82fM,12      fM,22=fM,1210.8211=1.78fM,12  cM=4π2M2  fM,22=2π2×150×1.78×41.97=9.27×106Nm=9.27kNmm

Problem c)

Eigenfrequency with both masses is approximated with Dunkerley’s summation theorem. First built-in ends are assumed.

See Table 30 and the previous problem (Problem 8.3 b)).
1f12=1fm,12+1fM,12      f1=148.112+141.9820.5=31.63 Hz

The natural frequency of the beam supported by springs with uniform and additional concentrated masses is

Eq.(8-15).
1f221fM2=4π22cmL+M

Fundamental frequency of the beam with both masses can be approximated by Föppl’s summation theorem.

See Table 30 and Eq.(8-59).
1f2=1f12+1f22      1f2=131.632+4π2(mL+M)2c

Spring constant is expressed from the condition that the natural frequency must be reduced by 20%.

See Table 30 and Eq.(8-59).
f=0.8f1=    1f12+1f221=0.82f12      f22=f1210.8211=1.78f12  c=4π2(mL+M)2  f22=2π2×(42.2×7.0+150)×1.78×31.632=15.63×106Nm=15.63kNmm